Receiving an IRS Notice of Deficiency is a serious matter because taxpayers generally have only 90 days to challenge the proposed tax in the United States Tax Court. Missing that deadline can eliminate an important opportunity to dispute the additional tax before paying it.
A federal appeals court ruling issued November 18, 2026 has added an important development to this area of tax procedure. In Laurenzano v. Commissioner, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held that the statutory filing deadline may be extended through equitable tolling in appropriate circumstances.
The ruling does not mean that taxpayers can ignore the 90 day deadline or automatically obtain relief after filing late. Courts remain divided, and California taxpayers face a particularly important limitation under existing Ninth Circuit precedent.
For taxpayers dealing with a substantial IRS assessment, understanding which notice was received, the applicable filing deadline, and the available procedural rights remains essential.
Key takeaway:
The Fourth Circuit has joined several other federal appellate courts in recognizing that equitable tolling may apply to the 90 day Tax Court petition deadline under Internal Revenue Code Section 6213(a).
However, equitable tolling requires more than a missed deadline. The taxpayer generally must demonstrate diligent efforts to pursue the claim and extraordinary circumstances that prevented timely filing. Relief is not automatic, and contrary appellate precedent remains important in California.
What Is an IRS Notice of Deficiency?
An IRS Notice of Deficiency, sometimes called a statutory notice of deficiency or 90 day letter, formally informs a taxpayer that the IRS has determined additional tax is due.
Common examples include IRS Letter 3219 and Letter 531. The notice generally identifies the proposed deficiency and explains the taxpayer's right to seek review by the United States Tax Court.
Under Internal Revenue Code Sections 6212 and 6213, the IRS generally cannot assess the proposed deficiency during the statutory petition period. If a timely Tax Court petition is filed, assessment ordinarily remains restricted while the Tax Court proceeding is pending, subject to statutory exceptions.
This procedure gives taxpayers an opportunity to challenge the proposed additional tax without first paying the disputed deficiency.
How Long Does a Taxpayer Have to File?
Section 6213(a) generally provides 90 days after the IRS mails the Notice of Deficiency.
A separate 150 day period applies when the notice is addressed to a person outside the United States. The statutory rule should not be confused with simply traveling internationally during the filing period.
The statute also contains special rules concerning weekends, legal holidays, and the last filing date specified on the notice.
The deadline printed on the notice should always be reviewed against the governing statutory rules.
For an electronic petition filed through the Tax Court's DAWSON system, the filing generally must be completed by 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on the final permissible filing date.
Paper filings have separate delivery and timely mailing rules under Section 7502, including restrictions on designated private delivery services.
Corresponding with the IRS, providing supporting records, or requesting an administrative review generally does not suspend the statutory Tax Court petition deadline.
What Happened in Laurenzano v. Commissioner?
On September 9, 2024, the IRS mailed Peter Laurenzano a Notice of Deficiency proposing approximately $14,152 in additional income tax.
According to the court's opinion, Laurenzano was traveling in Florida and the Bahamas when the notice arrived at his Maryland address.
He believed that his international travel entitled him to the longer 150 day filing period.
Nevertheless, the Tax Court did not receive his petition until February 19, 2025, which was 163 days after the notice was mailed.
The Tax Court dismissed his petition because it concluded that the filing deadline was jurisdictional and could not be extended for equitable reasons.
Laurenzano appealed that dismissal to the Fourth Circuit.
The Fourth Circuit Rejected the Jurisdictional Interpretation
In its November 18, 2026 published opinion, the Fourth Circuit concluded that the petition deadline in Section 6213(a) is not jurisdictional.
A jurisdictional requirement determines whether a court possesses legal authority to hear a matter. If the filing period is jurisdictional, a court generally cannot excuse an untimely filing through equitable tolling.
A nonjurisdictional claim processing rule, by contrast, can be subject to equitable exceptions where Congress has not precluded them.
The Fourth Circuit concluded that Congress had not clearly made the 90 day petition deadline jurisdictional. It also determined that the ordinary presumption favoring equitable tolling applies.
The court therefore vacated the Tax Court's dismissal and returned the case for further proceedings.
The Court Did Not Grant Laurenzano an Extension
This distinction is particularly important.
The Fourth Circuit did not decide whether Laurenzano's travel, misunderstanding of the filing period, or other circumstances actually justified equitable tolling.
It held that the Tax Court has authority to consider the request under the applicable legal standard.
Whether Laurenzano ultimately qualifies for relief remains a separate factual question.
The Fourth Circuit's published Laurenzano opinion provides the court's complete legal analysis.
What Is Equitable Tolling?
Equitable tolling is a legal doctrine that may permit a court to excuse a missed filing deadline when circumstances beyond the litigant's reasonable control prevented a timely filing despite diligent efforts.
The Supreme Court has explained the general doctrine in cases including Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner, 596 U.S. 199 (2022), and Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin v. United States, 577 U.S. 250 (2016).
A taxpayer generally must address two substantive elements:
- Diligence: The taxpayer pursued the available legal rights with reasonable diligence.
- Extraordinary circumstances: Circumstances sufficiently beyond the taxpayer's control prevented filing within the required period.
The legal standard is demanding and depends heavily on the facts.
A taxpayer's misunderstanding, failure to read a notice, ordinary scheduling difficulties, or assumption that informal IRS correspondence would protect the deadline will not necessarily satisfy the test.
The mere fact that a petition was filed shortly after the deadline does not establish entitlement to tolling.
When evaluating potential relief, the actual timeline and evidence explaining why the petition could not be filed on time are essential.
Federal Courts Are Divided on the 90 Day Deadline
The Laurenzano decision is part of a broader disagreement among federal appellate courts over the interpretation of Section 6213(a).
Several courts have concluded that the deadline is nonjurisdictional and that equitable tolling may be available.
Other courts have reached different conclusions about whether the deadline is jurisdictional or whether Congress intended to permit equitable tolling.
| Federal appellate court | Relevant decision | General holding |
|---|---|---|
| Second Circuit | Buller v. Commissioner (2025) | Equitable tolling may apply |
| Third Circuit | Culp v. Commissioner (2023) | Equitable tolling may apply |
| Fourth Circuit | Laurenzano v. Commissioner (2026) | Equitable tolling may apply |
| Sixth Circuit | Oquendo v. Commissioner (2025) | Equitable tolling may apply |
| Eighth Circuit | Maniktala v. Commissioner (2026) | Equitable tolling may apply |
| First Circuit | Kyick Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner (2026) | Deadline is nonjurisdictional, but equitable tolling is unavailable |
| Ninth Circuit | Organic Cannabis Foundation, LLC v. Commissioner (2020) | Earlier precedent treated deadline as jurisdictional |
These decisions illustrate why the procedural position of a taxpayer cannot be determined from the Fourth Circuit's ruling alone.
The controlling appellate jurisdiction, the chronology of relevant precedent, and any subsequent higher court decisions must be considered.
What Does This Mean for California Taxpayers?
California taxpayers should be particularly careful about assuming that the new Fourth Circuit decision provides a right to file a late Tax Court petition.
In Organic Cannabis Foundation, LLC v. Commissioner, 962 F.3d 1082 (9th Cir. 2020), the Ninth Circuit treated Section 6213(a)'s filing deadline as jurisdictional and rejected equitable tolling.
That opinion was issued before the Supreme Court's 2022 decision in Boechler, which held that a different Tax Court filing deadline under Section 6330(d)(1) was nonjurisdictional and subject to equitable tolling.
Subsequent appellate decisions have relied on Boechler to reconsider the treatment of Section 6213(a), but the Ninth Circuit has not adopted the Fourth Circuit's new conclusion in a controlling published post-Boechler decision.
Whether intervening Supreme Court authority permits departure from the Ninth Circuit's earlier precedent remains a significant legal issue.
For a California taxpayer whose Tax Court decision would ordinarily be reviewed by the Ninth Circuit, the prudent approach remains to treat the statutory petition deadline as strictly enforceable.
A taxpayer with an already missed deadline should not assume that relief is categorically available or categorically impossible without evaluating the controlling law and specific facts.
What Should You Do if You Missed the Tax Court Deadline?
A missed deadline requires a careful review of the actual Notice of Deficiency and the relevant procedural history.
Several distinct issues should be considered before concluding that the opportunity to challenge the proposed assessment has expired.
1. Confirm the Notice and Applicable Filing Period
Not every IRS notice is a statutory Notice of Deficiency.
A CP2000 proposes adjustments based on differences between information returns and an individual's tax return, but it is not itself a statutory Notice of Deficiency.
A taxpayer who receives a CP2000 may still have opportunities to respond administratively before the IRS issues a deficiency notice.
For more information, see my article explaining what an IRS CP2000 notice means and how to respond.
2. Verify How the Filing Deadline Was Calculated
The review should consider the notice mailing date, the address used by the IRS, the deadline printed on the notice, applicable holidays, and any statutory extension or suspension.
Special provisions can affect deadlines in bankruptcy proceedings, federally declared disasters, military service in qualifying circumstances, and certain other situations.
A claimed timely mailing also requires review of the relevant Section 7502 requirements and supporting evidence.
3. Determine Whether Equitable Tolling Is Legally Available
The legal analysis depends on the appellate jurisdiction that would ordinarily review the Tax Court proceeding.
The Fourth Circuit's opinion provides persuasive authority in other jurisdictions, but it does not automatically supersede contrary appellate precedent.
If equitable tolling is potentially available, a separate factual analysis is necessary.
4. Preserve Evidence of the Circumstances and Timeline
Relevant records can include:
- The complete IRS Notice of Deficiency and mailing envelope.
- Correspondence documenting when the taxpayer learned of the notice.
- Mailing receipts or electronic filing records.
- Records establishing the extraordinary circumstances claimed.
- Evidence of efforts to obtain assistance or file the petition.
- Other documents explaining the delay and the actions taken after the obstacle ended.
The evidence must support both the existence of an extraordinary circumstance and reasonable diligence.
5. Evaluate Any Remaining Administrative Remedies
If the deficiency has already been assessed, other procedures may remain available depending on the underlying tax liability and procedural history.
These can include audit reconsideration, an appropriate refund claim after payment, or other statutory administrative or judicial procedures when their requirements are satisfied.
A refund lawsuit is generally governed by separate jurisdictional, payment, and limitation rules. It is not simply an alternative Tax Court petition with the same requirements.
The specific avenue must be selected based on the notice, assessment, payments, and applicable statute.
If you received an IRS notice and are uncertain which deadline or response procedure applies, Schedule a Consultation for an initial review of the notice and available administrative options.
A Missed Filing Deadline Is Different From a Request for Penalty Relief
Taxpayers sometimes assume that reasonable cause for missing a tax filing or payment deadline also establishes grounds for extending a Tax Court petition deadline.
These are different legal issues.
Relief from certain penalties under Sections 6651 and 6664 involves standards that differ from the equitable tolling doctrine applicable to court filing deadlines.
For example, an illness or extraordinary event may be relevant to both analyses, but the evidence, statutory requirements, and potential remedies are not identical.
A taxpayer requesting administrative penalty relief should also separately protect any statutory petition deadline.
For a discussion of penalty relief provisions, see my article on IRS penalty abatement, reasonable cause, and administrative relief.
Why Responding to IRS Notices Promptly Still Matters
The new appellate decision should not change how taxpayers approach an IRS notice that contains an approaching statutory deadline.
A timely response remains the most reliable way to preserve available rights.
The Tax Court filing period is distinct from administrative IRS response deadlines, and not every communication to the IRS protects the right to petition the court.
The first step should be identifying whether the notice proposes an adjustment, formally determines a deficiency, assesses an existing liability, or initiates a collection procedure.
The underlying income tax issues should also be reviewed before agreeing with the IRS. A proposed assessment may involve incorrect cost basis, duplicated income, omitted payments, business deductions, or other factual or legal discrepancies.
My IRS notice review and response services focus on identifying the actual notice, evaluating the proposed tax, reviewing supporting records and IRS transcripts, and determining the appropriate administrative response.
For additional background on statutory deadlines and the limits on IRS assessments, see my discussion of the Taxpayer Bill of Rights and the right to finality.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I file a Tax Court petition after the 90 day deadline?
A late petition generally faces dismissal. However, recent federal appellate decisions recognize the potential availability of equitable tolling in certain jurisdictions and circumstances. Contrary precedent remains relevant, particularly in California.
Does the November 2026 Laurenzano decision automatically reopen late petitions?
No. The Fourth Circuit held that the Tax Court may consider equitable tolling in appropriate cases. It did not authorize automatic extensions or decide that the taxpayer in Laurenzano qualified for relief.
What if I was outside the United States when the IRS mailed the notice?
Section 6213(a) provides a separate 150 day period when the notice is addressed to a person outside the United States. International travel alone should not be assumed to satisfy that requirement. The notice, mailing circumstances, and controlling law must be examined.
Does contacting the IRS extend my Tax Court deadline?
Generally, no. Ordinary correspondence, an administrative disagreement, or a pending request for additional information does not automatically extend the statutory petition period.
Does the new decision apply to California?
It is not binding Ninth Circuit precedent. California taxpayers must account for the Ninth Circuit's earlier contrary decision in Organic Cannabis Foundation and the effect, if any, of intervening Supreme Court authority.
What if the IRS already assessed the tax?
The possible remedies depend on the assessment history, the underlying tax, the taxpayer's payments, and other procedural requirements. Audit reconsideration, refund procedures, or other available remedies may need to be evaluated separately.
Final Takeaway
The November 18, 2026 Fourth Circuit decision in Laurenzano v. Commissioner is an important development in federal tax procedure.
It recognizes that the statutory deadline to petition the Tax Court under Section 6213(a) may be subject to equitable tolling in appropriate cases, adding to a developing body of appellate authority.
However, the decision does not create a nationwide automatic extension, resolve the existing circuit conflict, or guarantee that a taxpayer who misses the deadline will obtain relief.
The most effective response remains prompt review of every IRS notice, accurate identification of its statutory deadline, and preservation of the taxpayer's available administrative and judicial rights.